Gigi Edgley Host Brian Henson Judge, Executive Producer Beth Hathaway Judge Kirk R. Thatcher Judge Peter Brooke Self John Criswell Self Julie Zobel Self Ben Bayouth Contestant Chaz Vance Contestant Ivonne Escoto Contestant Jake Corrick Contestant Josh Smith Contestant Lex Rudd Contestant Melissa Doss Contestant Robert Bennett Contestant Russ Adams Contestant Tina Roland Contestant Lisa Henson Executive Producer Joseph Freed Executive Producer Rob Bagshaw Executive Producer