Jenny McCarthy Host Tim Parrish Contestant Jason Holmes Contestant Benjamin Clark Contestant Aaron Chase Contestant Jesse Wilson Contestant Kenneth Barrington Contestant Christian Seklecki Contestant Ali Leitza Contestant Summer Mack Contestant Shauna Dillard Contestant Yanina Beccaria Contestant Tara Locke Contestant Cina Luks Contestant Jenny Blatt Contestant Jason Ewell Contestant Leo Borriello Contestant Franky Arriola Contestant Mike Sweet Contestant Ryan Smith Contestant Darwin Zook Contestant Quaison "Q" Dodd Contestant Darren McMullen Host Tom Shelly Executive Producer