Anne Hathaway Lexi Actor Gary Carr Jeff Actor Quincy Tyler Bernstine Sylvia Actor Judd Hirsch Cop , Vendor , Taxi Driver Actor Savvy Crawford Young Lexi Actor Daphne Zelle Waitress Actor Jane Beaird Adolescent Lexi Actor Delaney Moro Roommate Actor John Carney Executive Producer, Writer, Director Todd Hoffman Executive Producer Sam Dolnick Executive Producer Choire Sicha Executive Producer