Zooey Deschanel Jess Day Actor Jake Johnson Nick Actor Max Greenfield Schmidt Actor Lamorne Morris Winston Actor Hannah Simone Cece Actor Linda Cardellini Abby Day Guest Star Jon Lovitz Rabbi Guest Star Jessica Chaffin Bertie Guest Star Damon Wayans Jr. Coach Guest Star Steve Agee Outside Dave Guest Star Allyn Rachel Rachael Guest Star Bunny Levine Shirley Guest Star Jay Hawkins Cop Guest Star Jeanette Branch Tat'd Up Gal Guest Star Elizabeth Meriwether Executive Producer Jake Kasdan Executive Producer Peter Chernin Executive Producer Katherine Pope Executive Producer Dave Finkel Executive Producer Brett Baer Executive Producer