David Boreanaz Jason Hayes Actor Max Thieriot Clay Spenser Actor Neil Brown Jr. Ray Actor A.J. Buckley Sonny Actor Toni Trucks Davis Actor Jessica Paré Mandy Ellis Actor Michaela McManus Alana Guest Star Tyler Grey Trent Guest Star Judd Lormand Blackburn Guest Star Alona Tal Stella Guest Star Brian Howe Oliver Guest Star Zoran Radanovich Luka Baljic Guest Star Gil Darnell Jakub Kowal Guest Star Alen Toric Lucaz Guest Star Ray Campbell Mr. Langston Guest Star Christopher Rivas Keith Guest Star C. Thomas Howell Ash Spenser Guest Star Paul Cassell Manager Rick Guest Star Larissa Vereza Tourist Woman Guest Star Bernadette Speakes Woman Guest Star Gemma Brooke Allen Terrified Child 1 Guest Star Caige Coulter Terrified Child 2 Guest Star Callum Joyce Terrified Child 3 Guest Star Lindalee Czarnecki Terrified Child 4 Guest Star Benjamin Cavell Executive Producer, Writer Ed Redlich Executive Producer Christopher Chulack Executive Producer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer Daniele Nathanson Writer Larry Teng Director