David Boreanaz Jason Hayes Actor Max Thieriot Clay Spenser Actor Neil Brown Jr. Ray Perry Actor A.J. Buckley Sonny Quinn Actor Toni Trucks Lisa Davis Actor Jessica Paré Mandy Ellis Actor Judd Lormand Lieutenant Commander Eric Blackburn Actor Tyler Grey Trent Guest Star Parisa Fakhri Naima Guest Star Tony Curran Brett Swann Guest Star Michael Weaver Col. Smith Guest Star Samantha Sloyan Victoria Seaver Guest Star Christopher Mychael Watson Andre Guest Star Susie Abromeit Jamie Guest Star Chloe Dworkin Local girl 1 Guest Star Claire Chapelli Lilly Guest Star Jamie Martz Marine Lt. Guest Star Sammy Horowitz Nick, Foxtrot 4 Guest Star Melissa Collins Local girl 2 Guest Star Benjamin Cavell Executive Producer Ed Redlich Executive Producer Christopher Chulack Executive Producer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer Julian Silver Writer Reiss Clauson-Wolf Writer James M. Muro Director