Tom Mison Ichabod Crane Actor Nicole Beharie Lt. Abbie Mills Actor Orlando Jones Captain Frank Irving Actor Katia Winter Katrina Crane Actor John Noble Henry Parish Actor Lyndie Greenwood Jenny Mills Actor Matt Barr Guest Star Sakina Jaffrey Guest Star Neil Jackson Guest Star Surely Alvelo Guest Star Stephen Michael Ayers Guest Star Shaun Clay Guest Star Kimberley Drummond Guest Star Marc Farley Guest Star Megan Hayes Guest Star Joy Jacobson Guest Star Jeremy Owens Guest Star Scott Poythress Guest Star Alex Kurtzman Executive Producer Roberto Orci Executive Producer Len Wiseman Executive Producer Heather Kadin Executive Producer