Matt Lambert Creator, Writer Mena Suvari Maria Abascal Actor Zachary Booth David Actor Bill Irwin Enos Abascal Actor Drew Moerlein Dusty Actor Lamman Rucker Rev. Elijah Bledsoe Actor Paulina Singer Grace Actor Lydia Hearst Charlotte Roberts Actor Slate Holmgren Sweetmouth Actor Luna Lauren Velez Terra Actor Mark Jeffrey Miller Pastor Bowe Guest Star Clark Middleton Corky Guest Star Allyson Ryan Brenda Culland Guest Star Hunter Wenzel Jeremy Culland Guest Star Wayne Pere Tory Culland Guest Star Helen Bowman Guest Star James Manos Jr. Guest Star, Executive Producer Spencer Kennard Chester Guest Star Jason Blum Executive Producer Gerard Bocaccio Executive Producer Stewart Till Executive Producer Gene Stein Executive Producer Erica Motley Executive Producer Eli Roth Executive Producer, Director