Dale Robertson Jim Hardie Actor Chuck Connors Button Smith, Pete Johnson Guest Star Michael Landon Tad Cameron Guest Star Lee Van Cleef Cherokee Bob Guest Star Victor Millan Manuel Guest Star Alan Reynolds Guest Star Joe De Santis Garrett Guest Star Russell Thorson Wells Fargo Manager Jefferson Guest Star Tom McKee Sheriff Plummer Guest Star Arthur Space Willow Creek Sheriff Guest Star Trevor Bardette Captain John C. Plumber Guest Star Glenn Strange Guest Star Rico Alaniz Sebastian Guest Star Chris Drake Charlie Ford Guest Star Ric Roman Seaborn Barnes Guest Star Kit Carson Outlaw Leader Guest Star Tom McDonough Gage Guest Star Boyd Stockman Buzz Crabtree Guest Star Nesdon Booth Walter Bassett Guest Star Cheryl Callaway Abby Turner Guest Star William F. Leicester Writer George Waggner Director Steve Fisher Writer Dwight Newton Writer Frank Gruber Writer N. B. Stone Jr. Writer Sloan Nibley Writer John English Director John K. Butler Writer Sidney Salkow Director Leslie H. Martinson Director Lewis R. Foster Director Allen H. Miner Director George F. Slavin Writer Jerry Hopper Director