Lezlye Donahue Contestant Bill Germanakos Contestant Jim Germanakos Contestant Patty Gonzalez Contestant David Griffin Contestant Julie Hadden Contestant Phil Hawk Contestant Jerry Lisenby Contestant Jez Luckett Contestant Nicole Michalik Contestant Isabeau Miller Contestant Ryan Rodriguez Contestant Hollie Self Contestant Neil Tejwani Contestant Amber Walker Contestant Bryan Washington Contestant Kae Whang Contestant Amy Zimmer Contestant Alison Sweeney Host Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer John Foy Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer