Alison Sweeney Host Rebecca "Becky" Comet Contestant Mike Danley Contestant Antone Davis Contestant Patrick Ferrari Contestant John "Johnny" Forger Contestant Bonnie Griffin Contestant Vencent "Vinny" Hickerson Contestant Jessica Limpert Contestant Deborah "Debbie" Lounds Contestant Ramon Medeiros Contestant Joe Mitchell Contestant Courtney Rainville Contestant John Rhode Contestant Jennifer Rumple Contestant Sunny Sinclair Contestant Olivia Ward Guest Star Ken Paves Guest Star Devin Alexander Guest Star Ali Vincent Guest Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer John Foy Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer