Alison Sweeney Host Fernanda Abarca Contestant Craig Arrington Contestant Chelsea Arthurs Contestant David Brown Contestant Rachel Frederickson Contestant Hap Holmstead Contestant Matt Hooper Contestant Holley Mangold Contestant Jennifer Messer Contestant Tumi Oguntala Contestant Marie Pearl Contestant Bobby Saleem Contestant Jay Sheets Contestant Ruben Studdard Contestant Tanya Winfield Contestant David Foster Guest Star Danni Allen Guest Star Apolo Ohno Guest Ken Paves Guest Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer Todd Lubin Executive Producer Lisa Hennessy Executive Producer Eden Gaha Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer