Paul Walter Hauser Sheep Voice Yvonne Orji Pigeon Voice Romy Fay Abby Voice Danny Nucci Abba Voice Zehra Fazal Eema Voice Jonathan Roumie Jesus Voice Jordin Sparks Fish Voice Paras Patel Matthew Voice Elizabeth Tabish Mary Voice Noah James Andrew Voice Joey Vahedi Thomas Voice George H. Xanthis John Voice Yasmine Al-Bustami Ramah Voice Brandon Potter Quintus Voice Julian Grant Cyrius Maximus Voice Ryan Swanson Writer, Executive Producer Dallas Jenkins Executive Producer Chad Gundersen Executive Producer Keith Alcorn Executive Producer Kellen Erskine Executive Producer Derral Eves Executive Producer