Mark Duplass Pete Actor Steve Rannazzisi Kevin Actor Nick Kroll Ruxin Actor Paul Scheer Andre Actor Jon Lajoie Taco Actor Katie Aselton Jenny Actor Nadine Velazquez Sofia Guest Star Brie Larson Ashley Guest Star Matthew Berry Himself Guest Star Stephanie Lemelin Waitress Guest Star Sara Erikson Vanessa Guest Star Devon Abner Hotel Bartender Guest Star Sam Vance Football Announcer Guest Star Andrea de Oliveira Melanie B. Guest Star Jeff Schaffer Executive Producer Jackie Marcus Schaffer Executive Producer