Mark Duplass Pete Actor Steve Rannazzisi Kevin Actor Nick Kroll Ruxin Actor Paul Scheer Andre Actor Jon Lajoie Taco Actor Katie Aselton Jenny Actor Timothy Olyphant Sushi Chef Guest Star Ryan Hansen Ben Guest Star Kenji Nakamura Japanese Sushi Chef Guest Star Frederick Lawrence Paintball Employee Guest Star Elizabeth Hendrickson Abby Guest Star Jeff Schaffer Executive Producer Jackie Marcus Schaffer Executive Producer