Mark Duplass Pete Actor Steve Rannazzisi Kevin Actor Nick Kroll Ruxin Actor Paul Scheer Andre Actor Jon Lajoie Taco Actor Katie Aselton Jenny Actor Erin Heatherton Coach Crowley Guest Star Alina Foley Ellie Guest Star Brett Gelman Gavin Guest Star Ali Larter Georgia Thompson Guest Star Andy Buckley Tony Thompson Guest Star Eric Pumphrey Men's Boutique Worker Guest Star Elaine Carroll Credit Card Lady Guest Star Dale Waddington Screaming Lady Guest Star Jeff Schaffer Executive Producer Jackie Marcus Schaffer Executive Producer