Kaitlin Olson Mickey Actor Thomas Barbusca Chip Actor Sofia Black-D'Elia Sabrina Actor Jack Stanton Ben Actor Carla Jimenez Alba Actor Scott MacArthur Jimmy Actor E.J. Callahan Colonel Pemberton Guest Star Caitlin Carmichael Madison Guest Star Lela Jane Cortines Farble Guest Star Jay Mohr Bert Guest Star Wayne Wilderson Principal Gibbons Guest Star Landon Gimenez Saputo Guest Star Bryan Keith Officer Guest Star John Chernin Executive Producer Dave Chernin Executive Producer Nick Frenkel Executive Producer Oliver Obst Executive Producer Randall Einhorn Executive Producer