Bill Pullman Detective Harry Ambrose Actor Jessica Biel Cora Tannetti Actor, Executive Producer Christopher Abbott Mason Tannetti Actor Dohn Norwood Dan Leroy Actor Abby Miller Caitlin Sullivan Actor Jacob Pitts J.D. Actor Joanna P. Adler Captain Anne Farmer Actor Nadia Alexander Adult Phoebe (19) Actor Enid Graham Elizabeth Lacey Actor C.J. Wilson William Actor Susan Pourfar Cora's Public Defender Actor Joseph Melendez District Attorney Lopez Actor Peggy Gormley Judge Barrett Actor Kathryn Erbe Fay Ambrose Actor Meredith Holzman Sharon Actor Danielle Burgess Maddie Actor Lindsay Torrey Abbi Grayston Actor Grant Monohon Duffy Actor Danielle Herbert Jail Clerk Actor Derek Simonds Executive Producer Brad Winters Executive Producer Ellen Fairey Co-Executive Producer Jesse McKeown Co-Executive Producer Jody Lee Lipes Director Tom Pabst Writer