Pierce Brosnan Eli McCullough Actor Jacob Lofland Young Eli McCullough Actor Sydney Lucas Jeannie McCullough Actor David Wilson Barnes Phineas McCullough Actor Jess Weixler Sally McCullough Actor Henry Garrett Pete McCullough Actor Elizabeth Frances Prairie Flower Actor Paola Núñez Maria Garcia Actor James Parks Niles Gilbert Actor Zahn McClarnon Toshaway Actor Kathryn Prescott Young Ingrid Actor Shane Graham Charles McCullough Actor Jeremy Bobb Guest Star Duke Davis Roberts Guest Star Glenn Stanton Guest Star Caleb Burgess Guest Star Joe Nemmers Guest Star Kevin Page Guest Star Philipp Meyer Executive Producer Lee Shipman Executive Producer Brian McGreevy Executive Producer Mike Nelson Executive Producer Jenna Santoianni Executive Producer Ellen Kuras Director Rob Askins Writer Henry Bronchtein Producer Julia Ruchman Producer Kevin Dowling Producer Daniel C. Connolly Producer Paul Leonard Producer Melanie Marnich Producer