Rotten Tomatoes
Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

The Yogurt Shop Murders – Season 1, Episode 2 The Fifth Victim

Play trailer The Yogurt Shop Murders – Season 1, Episode 2 The Fifth Victim Aired Aug 10, 2025 Documentary Crime Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
Tomatometer 0 Reviews
Trauma continues to haunt the community as family members search for healing, resolution, and ways to hold on to the memories of the girls. The initial suspicions around the four teenage boys lead nowhere. After several false leads and wrongful arrests, homicide supervisor Hector Polanco is found to have coerced a suspect into a false confession and is reassigned. Lead investigator John Jones is diagnosed with PTSD and is taken off the case, suffering guilt about the department’s inability to solve the murders. The family of Amy Ayers even turns to a private investigator in their frustration with the lack of progress. Eight years after the murders, new lead investigator Paul Johnson revisits the case and an interrogation video reveals Rob Springsteen claiming to have seen Maurice Pierce with a gun in his hand on the night of the murders.
Watch on HBO Max Stream Now

Where to Watch

The Yogurt Shop Murders — Season 1, Episode 2

More Like This

View All
Vanished: The Heather Elvis Case 100% 100% Vanished: The Heather Elvis Case Watchlist American Nightmare 96% 89% American Nightmare Watchlist TRAILER for American Nightmare The Program: Cons, Cults, and Kidnapping 100% 88% The Program: Cons, Cults, and Kidnapping Watchlist TRAILER for The Program: Cons, Cults, and Kidnapping Murder in Boston: Roots, Rampage & Reckoning 100% 93% Murder in Boston: Roots, Rampage & Reckoning Watchlist TRAILER for Murder in Boston: Roots, Rampage & Reckoning Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist 80% 81% Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Cast & Crew

View All

Beverly Lowry

Self

Claire Huie

Self

John Jones

Self

Robert Ayers

Self

Nancy Abraham

Executive Producer

Avi Belkin

Executive Producer
View All

The Yogurt Shop Murders — Season 1, Episode 2

The Yogurt Shop Murders View more photos

Episode Info

Synopsis Trauma continues to haunt the community as family members search for healing, resolution, and ways to hold on to the memories of the girls. The initial suspicions around the four teenage boys lead nowhere. After several false leads and wrongful arrests, homicide supervisor Hector Polanco is found to have coerced a suspect into a false confession and is reassigned. Lead investigator John Jones is diagnosed with PTSD and is taken off the case, suffering guilt about the department’s inability to solve the murders. The family of Amy Ayers even turns to a private investigator in their frustration with the lack of progress. Eight years after the murders, new lead investigator Paul Johnson revisits the case and an interrogation video reveals Rob Springsteen claiming to have seen Maurice Pierce with a gun in his hand on the night of the murders.
Director
Margaret Brown
Executive Producer
Nancy Abraham, Avi Belkin, Beth Garrabrant, Lisa Heller, Ali Herting, Dave McCary, Emily Osborne, Sara Rodriguez, Limor Gott Ronen, Mickey Stanley, Emma Stone, Nicole Stott
Network
HBO Max
Rating
TV-MA
Genre
Documentary, Crime
Original Language
English
Release Date
Aug 10, 2025