Poppy Montgomery Carrie Wells Actor Dylan Walsh Detective Al Burns Actor Jane Curtin Joanne Webster Actor Dallas Roberts Eliot Delson Actor Tawny Cypress Cherie Rollins-Murray Actor James Hiroyuki Liao Jay Lee Actor Mark Nelson Dr. Eugene Lustig Guest Star Stephen Kunken Dale Parsons Guest Star Yvonna Kopacz-Wright Alwyn Pierce Guest Star Phyllis Somerville Ruth Guest Star Robert T. Bogue Todd Blasingame Guest Star Sherry Boone Lena Guest Star Joel Reuben Ganz Tomas Guest Star Katina Corraro Mary Guest Star Jonathan David Martin Faculty Host Guest Star Rob Morrison Assistant Guest Star Ben Rosenblatt Twenty-Something 2 Guest Star Rafael Alejandro Benoit Twenty-Something 1 Guest Star Alix Cross Linda Miller Guest Star Makenzie Leigh Celine Emminger Guest Star Erica Sinner Murder Victim Guest Star Roger Brenner NYPD , Officer Guest Star Ed Redlich Executive Producer John Bellucci Executive Producer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer Sam Montgomery Writer Peter Werner Director