Kristen Bell Veronica Mars Actor Percy Daggs III Wallace Fennel Actor Teddy Dunn Duncan Kane Actor Jason Dohring Logan Echolls Actor Francis Capra Eli "Weevil" Navarro Actor Enrico Colantoni Keith Mars Actor Sydney Tamiia Poitier Mallory Dent Actor Jeff Rector Guest Star Michael Muhney Sheriff Don Lamb Guest Star Katie Leclerc Guest Star Seraina Jacqueline Guest Star Max Greenfield Guest Star Amber Ojeda Guest Star Steve Monroe Guest Star Michael Drummond Guest Star Courtney Gebhart Guest Star Michael Canaan Guest Star Aaron Paul Guest Star Justin Lang Guest Star Tina Majorino Cindy "Mac" Mackenzie Guest Star Misty Connelly Guest Star Brandon Hillock Deputy Jerry Sacks Guest Star Bridget Hoffman Ellen Sinclair Guest Star Amanda Noret Madison Sinclair Guest Star Jared Hillman Jackson Douglas Guest Star Erin Cronican Security Guard Guest Star David Grant Wright Samuel Mackenzie Guest Star David Dantes Bass Player Guest Star DeAnna Driscoll Distraught Woman Guest Star Joel Silver Executive Producer Rob Thomas Executive Producer John T. Kretchmer Director Jed Seidel Writer Lynne North Writer