Broken Arrow

1950

Broken Arrow

Critics Consensus

No consensus yet.

89%

TOMATOMETER

Total Count: 9

70%

Audience Score

User Ratings: 1,021
User image

Broken Arrow Photos

Movie Info

Indian scout Tom Jeffords (James Stewart) is sent out to stem the war between the Whites and Apaches in the late 1870s. He learns (through an uncomfortably close encounter) that the Indians kill only to protect themselves, or out of retaliation for white atrocities. Befriending the sagacious Apache leader Cochise (Jeff Chandler), Jeffords ensures safe passage for white mail-carriers through Indian territory. As he becomes closer to his Native American "brothers", Jeffords falls in love with and weds a pretty Apache girl (Debra Paget). This being a 1950 film (miscegenation was frowned upon by the Production Code), you can guess what happens to her. Jeffords wants to avenge his bride's death at the hands of white renegades, but it is the so-called "savage" Cochise who advises him not to. Having learned much from each other, Jeffords and Cochise symbolize the white/Indian detente with the traditional broken arrow. This superb, non-condescending film has been criticized in some circles because of the alleged depiction of Cochise as an Indian "Uncle Tom", and because actor Jeff Chandler was not a genuine Native American. Nonetheless, Broken Arrow stands the test of time far more successfully than the later, politically correct Dances with Wolves. In 1956, Broken Arrow was adapted into a TV series starring John Lupton as Jeffords and Michael Ansara as Cochise.

Watch it now

Cast

Critic Reviews for Broken Arrow

All Critics (9) | Top Critics (3) | Fresh (8) | Rotten (1)

  • Essentially it's an appealing, sentimental Indian romance, with plenty of action.

    Mar 26, 2009 | Full Review…

    Variety Staff

    Variety
    Top Critic
  • A fine film all the same, despite the compromised ending, quite beautifully shot by Ernest Palmer.

    Feb 9, 2006 | Full Review…
    Time Out
    Top Critic
  • We cannot accept this picture as either an exciting or reasonable account of the attitudes and ways of American Indians. They merit justice, but not such patronage.

    Jan 28, 2006 | Full Review…
  • This massively influential western from director Delmer Daves was among the first to tell the native American side of the story.

    Oct 23, 2015 | Rating: 4/5 | Full Review…
  • This superb western is one of the earliest to treat the problems of Indians seriously and sympathetically.

    Oct 23, 2015 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…
  • One of the first Hollywood movies to preach for accord between Native Americans and white civilization. While the liberal ideology is commendable, the portrayal of Cochise by white actor Jeff Chandler is not.

    May 7, 2006 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…

Audience Reviews for Broken Arrow

  • Sep 17, 2015
    A very underrated film, Broken Arrow deftly and handily tells a great story. Jeff Chandler turns in an excellent performance as miscast Cochise, playing the Apache leader with an admirable diligence and respect. James Stewart's turn as Tom Jeffords is surprisingly understated and memorable, not just in the usual likable Jimmy Stewart kind of way. I also love the briskness of the editing and overall direction.
    Paris S Super Reviewer
  • Sep 05, 2010
    James Stewart is cool in this movie trying to get the Europeans and Native Americans to get along. Both he and the audience learn a lot. Of course this isn't the best western, but I liked it.
    Aj V Super Reviewer
  • Jun 28, 2010
    I actually really like this and think it has a very nice message and sense of direction. James Stewart fits well into the earnest cowboy role, essentially becoming the peacemaker of Arizona. While some of the Indians don't come across as authentic looking, it doesn't really matter. I'd rather watch Jeff Chandler as Cochise than a real Native American who can't act. This is a very different type of Western and one that has a very unique quality to it.
    Conner R Super Reviewer
  • May 22, 2010
    Fine movie, well acted. This film portrays Cochise and many of the other Apaches as good people, which was a remarkable leap at the time.
    Morris N Super Reviewer

Broken Arrow Quotes

News & Features