Ross Katz Director Rose Byrne Justine Actor Nick Kroll Jake Actor, Producer Bobby Cannavale Danny Actor Joel McHale Hudson Actor Caleb Paddock Teddy Actor Matthew Paddock Teddy Actor Caitlin FitzGerald Kat Actor Paula Garcés Blanca Actor Josh Charles Phil Actor Jane Krakowski Miss Jenn Actor Bobby Moynihan Paul Actor Mike Birbiglia Braden Actor Jeff Cox Screenwriter Elizabeth Flahive Screenwriter Sam Slater Producer Paul Bernon Producer Marcus Cox Producer Karrie Cox Producer Jared Goldman Producer Mark Duplass Executive Producer Jay Duplass Executive Producer David Bernon Executive Producer Vanja Cernjul Cinematographer Paul Frank Film Editing Marcelo Zarvos Original Music Ola Maslik Production Design Amanda Bennett Set Decoration Alex Bovaird Costume Design Avy Kaufman Casting