Michael McGowan Director, Screenwriter, Producer Alison Pill Yoli Actor Sarah Gadon Elf Actor Amybeth McNulty Nora Actor Donal Logue Jake Actor Mare Winningham Lottie Actor Marin Almasi Young Yoli Actor Josh Bainbridge Irate Man Actor Boyd Banks Pastor Actor Racine Bebamikawe Nurse Actor Morgan I. Bedard Cop Actor Gabrielle Jennings Young Elf Actor Mimi Kuzyk Tina Actor Aly Mawji Actor Michael Musi Actor Tyler Levine Producer Patrice Theroux Producer Naveen Prasad Executive Producer Daniel Grant Cinematographer Orlee Buium Film Editor Danny Haeberlin Production Design Thalia Stefaniuk Art Director Karen Churma Set Decoration Renee Fontana Costume Designer Heidi Levitt Casting