Doug Campbell Director Ryan Newman Zoe Brady Actor Devon Werkheiser Jason Brady Actor Alyshia Ochse Laura , Sister Sophia Actor Helen Eigenberg Sister Rebecca Actor Lise Simms Cheryl Brady Actor Robert Leeshock Gavin Brady Actor Sloane Avery Sara Actor Hugh B. Holub Father Macey Actor James Handy Bishop O'Reilly Actor Josh Plasse Chris Actor Jordan Diambrini Pete Actor Barbara Kymlicka Screenwriter Robert Ballo Producer Ken Sanders Producer Timothy O. Johnson Executive Producer Steve Gurevitch Original Music Joseph M. Setele Cinematographer Clayton Woodhull Film Editing Jeff Hardwick Casting Lia Burton Production Design Danielle Lee Art Director Christy Mele Costume Design