Tim Garrick Director, Screenwriter Nat Wolff Rick Stevens Actor Selena Gomez Nina Pennington Actor Mary-Louise Parker Lucy Stevens, Saint Lola Actor Elisabeth Shue Pamela Bender, Saint Poppy Actor Dylan McDermott Jimmy Leach Actor Heather Graham Annette Stratton-Osborne Actor Ashley Rickards Kristen Stevens Actor Cary Elwes Joseph Stevens Actor Patrick Warburton Principal Basil Poole Actor Jason Lee Father Krumins Actor Gary Busey Chief Actor Austin Stowell Kevin Actor Scott Russell Screenwriter Miri Yoon Producer Andrew Lazar Producer Barry Quart Executive Producer Kevin Tang Executive Producer Mathew Rudenberg Cinematographer Matt Friedman Film Editing David Newman Original Music Gabor Norman Production Design Julie Ziah Art Director Justin Lieb Set Decoration Francine Jamison-Tanchuck Costume Design Kerry Barden Casting Paul Schnee Casting