Marianna Palka Jill Hart Director, Actor, Screenwriter Jason Ritter Bill Actor Jaime King Beth Actor Brighton Sharbino Tiffany Hart Actor Rio Mangini Max Hart Actor Kingston Foster Cindy Hart Actor Jason Maybaum Jed Actor Eric Edelstein Actor Bill Smitrovich Papa Actor Roger Guenveur Smith Steven Sheriff Actor Caroline Aaron Nana Actor Sol Rodríguez Annabelle Actor Jaime Moyer Plumber Joe Actor Michael Moran Producer Daniel Noah Producer Josh C. Waller Producer Elijah Wood Producer Sharon Bordas Executive Producer Elisa Lleras Executive Producer Michael M. McGuire Executive Producer Fernando Szew Executive Producer Lisa Whalen Executive Producer Armando Salas Cinematographer Brett W. Bachman Film Editing Morgan Z Whirledge Original Music Ryan Brett Puckett Production Design Adam Nungester Art Director Valerie Mores Costume Design Danielle Aufiero Casting Amber Horn Casting