Travis Mills Blacksmith, Fighter Director, Actor, Writer, Producer Jeremy London Webb Actor Matt Story Moses Loftin Actor Heather Fusari Lavinia Loftin Actor Creek Wilson John T Actor Michael LaCour Doctor Larkin Actor Michael D. Anglin Longino Actor Cotton Yancey Sheriff Dan Lee Actor Matthew R. Horton Silas Loftin Actor, Producer Britton Webb Crawford Loftin Actor Aspen Kennedy Wilson Marion Actor William E. Harris Preacher Actor Nic Roylance Miles Actor Chris Bosarge Joe Loftin Actor Raymond Soutullo Judge Actor Lamar Lott Church-goer Actor Melvin Pittman Prisoner Actor Damon Burks Jury Member Actor Miles Donald James Sauls Actor Katira Banks Church Girl Actor Kevin J. McGrath Hiram Actor Rajko Scarabin Prison Guard Actor Dorsey Carson McNair Actor Tom Humbarger Telegraph Operator Actor Mamie Davis Nurse Actor Josh Priest Daniels Actor Krystal Sherrod Saloon Girl Actor Matt Wymer Hobbs Actor Morgan Browning Jerome Actor Marlene Cupit Matt Actor Jake Milton Joe Gang Actor Dawn Streeck Mrs. Loftin Actor Markeith Coleman Ambrose Actor Tim Sherrod Warden Actor Stephanie Davis Holmes Churchmember Actor, Associate Producer Hugh Daniel Porter Church Member, Vigilante Actor William Perkins Farmer Actor Terry Key Vigilante Actor Beau Hale Vigilante Actor Nichole Henry Farmer's Wife Actor Kelly Porter Joe Gang Actor Caroline Quin Joe's Youngest Daughter Actor Olivia Quin Joe's Oldest Daughter Actor David H. Stevens Actor Nicholas Ryan Bain Huddleston Actor Bart Massey Bart Actor Calvin L. Franklin Sandy Actor Katie Hauer Producer Nicholas Fornwalt Cinematographer Marc Ridgeway Original Music Laura Cavett Production Design