Larry Shaw Director Majandra Delfino Celeste Blodgett Actor Nicholas Brendon Dana Blodgett, Harrison Actor Ethan Embry Kyle Halley Actor Michael Boisvert Mitch Tanzer Actor Jamie Robinson Xavier Actor Geoffrey Pounsett Bruce Actor Deborah Gibson Monica Actor Allegra Fulton Hilly Actor Janaya Stephens Lauren Rawley-Simms Actor Kathleen Laskey Pheobe Blodgett Actor Dwight McFee Howard Blodgett Actor Niamh Wilson Young Celeste Actor Alexander Conti Young Dana Actor Raven Dauda Tanya at Karaoke Bar Actor Sara Sahr Waitress at Wine Restaurant Actor Jean Pearson French Waiter Actor Michael Dunston Alberto Actor Abdi Nazemian Writer Micah Schraft Writer Greg Copeland Producer Bonnie Raskin Executive Producer Justin Rosenblatt Executive Producer Steve Golin Executive Producer Rudolf Blahacek Cinematographer Kaja Fehr Film Editing Douglas J. Cuomo Original Music Lindsey Hermer-Bell Production Design Michele Brady Art Director Jaclyn Shoub Set Decoration Christopher Hargadon Costume Design Tina Gerussi Casting