George Sherman Director Victor Mature Crazy Horse Actor Suzan Ball Black Shawl Actor John Lund Major Twist Actor Ray Danton Little Big Man Actor Keith Larsen Flying Hawk Actor Paul Guilfoyle Worm Actor David Janssen Lt. Colin Cartwright Actor Robert Warwick Spotted Tail Actor James Millican General Crook Actor Morris Ankrum Red Cloud Actor Donald Randolph Aaron Cartwright Actor Robert F. Simon Jeff Mantz Actor James Westerfield Caleb Mantz Actor Stuart Randall Old Man Afraid Actor Pat Hogan Dull Knife Actor Dennis Weaver Maj. Carlisle Actor William Alland Producer