Maggie Greenwald Director Alicia Witt Emma Reynolds Actor Colin Ferguson Morgan Shelby Actor Laura Leighton Andie Actor Jill Larson Rachel Jacobs Actor Mary Beth McDonough Caroline Reynolds Actor Ariane Rinehart Rumi Actor Jordan Dean Daniel Reynolds Actor José Ramón Rosario Joe Actor John Palladino Ian Tillman Actor Blair Lewin Anne Marie Reynolds Actor Fiona Morgan Quinn Sophie Actor Owen Dammacco Marco Actor Blair Busbee Maureen Actor Jack Hallett Rodney Actor Stephanie Berry Mary Bernadette Actor Debra Lord Cooke Grace Actor Claire Keane Young Emma Actor Gary Lindemann Cliff Reynolds Actor Jan Pessano The Librarian Actor Caitlin D. Fryers Screenwriter Andrew Gernhard Producer Erica Joseph Hunter Producer Danielle von Zerneck Executive Producer Branden James Maxham Cinematographer Keith Reamer Film Editing Michael Richard Plowman Original Music Christian Snell Production Design William J. O'Donnell Art Director Adrianne Davis Set Decoration Tammy Gibbens Costume Design Valerie McCaffrey Casting