Vincent McEveety Director, Producer Peter Falk Columbo Actor Rod Steiger Vincenzo Fortelli Actor George Wendt Graham McVeigh Actor Jeff Yagher Teddy McVeigh Actor Jay Acovone Bruno Romano Actor Linda Gehringer Lorraine Buchinsky Actor Bruce Kirby Sgt. Phil Brindle Actor Don Calfa Rudy Actor William Bogert Randall Thurston Actor Shani Wallis Gwen Actor John Finnegan Barney Actor Gerry Gibson Pat O'Connor Actor Justin Lord Lt. Albert Schiffer Actor Alex Henteloff Pawnbroker Actor Karen Mayo-Chandler Tiffany Keene Actor Richard Epcar Thug Actor Kate Benton Bayleaf Hostess Actor Frantz Turner Fingerprint Man Actor Ed McCready Man in Bar Actor David Sobel Waiter Actor Mark Eric Charbonneau Bayleaf Waiter Actor Jim Bockelman Patrolman Kelleher Actor Marshall Nord Deputy Actor Nancy Ragan Ruth Actor Gerry Okuneff Walter Sterling Actor Johnny Carbajal Emilio Actor Christopher Seiter Producer