P.J. Pesce Scared Mustachioed Cowboy Director, Actor Sam Elliott Marshall Bill Speakes Actor Craig Sheffer Jack Cooper Actor Linda Fiorentino Sarah O'Rourke Actor Frank Whaley Walter Cooper Actor John Furlong Zeb Hollister Actor Robin Westphal Mamie Hollister Actor Boots Southerland Scar Face Leader Actor Joey Hamlin Laughing Boy Killer Actor Danny O'Haco Happy Actor Bradley Whitford Tommy Donnelly Actor Jill Scott Momaday Janie Actor R.L. Tolbert Lean Poker Player Actor Rockne Tarkington Packo Actor Michael Huddleston Clyde Actor Peter Gregory Dry Goods Clerk Actor George Cook Swedish Farmer Actor Elliot Tolbert Michael Actor Andrea Camarena Lindsay Katrin Actor Jerry Gardner Sheriff Whitaker Actor Sam Gauny Wells Fargo Clerk Actor Wally Welch Sanchez Actor Tom Berto Stage Driver Actor Ramon Frank Shotgun Actor Jeff O'Haco Frenchy Actor Tom Abrams Red Actor Jon Maldonado Marvin Actor Malissa Feruzzi Kate Jessie Actor Cecile Krevoy Con Woman in Saloon Actor Gretchen Becker Con Woman in Saloon Actor Brad Krevoy Producer Steven Stabler Producer