Adam Keleman Director, Screenwriter, Producer Caroline Dhavernas Sherry Actor McCaleb Burnett Henry Actor Elizabeth Marvel Abby Actor Charlie Hofheimer Norman Actor Daniel Eric Gold Ted Actor Jen Richards Danny Actor C.J. Wilson Fred Actor Taylor Richardson Alice Actor Mary Catherine Garrison Trish Actor David Aaron Baker Alan Gilmore Actor Quincy Tyler Bernstine Liz Actor Stephen O'Reilly Phil Actor Ryan Barry Mitch Actor Laura Wagner Producer Jason Dreyer Executive Producer David Moscow Executive Producer Todd Remis Executive Producer James West Cinematographer Drew DeNicola Film Editing Christopher Radcliff Film Editing Justin Bates Original Music Sarah Maiorino Costume Design Henry Russell Bergstein Casting