Alan Metzger Director Gary Cole Pete Nash Actor Mary Kay Place Betty Ann Dustin Actor Nicholle Tom Amy Dustin Actor Mac Davis Norm Dustin Actor Alyson Hannigan Kelly Actor Sara Rue Kimberly Jones Actor Tom Virtue Principal Arnet Actor Teddi Siddall Ellie Mills Actor W. K. Stratton Actor Abraham Alvarez Mark Billington Actor Cliff Bemis Tom Fowler Actor Pamela Clay Mother 2 Actor Jane Leigh Connelly Actor John H. Evans L.V. Gaines Actor Maggie Fleming Mrs. Cameron Actor Leanne Harris Bobbi Actor Charles Lucia Stan Vogler Actor Ken Magee Brad Allen Actor Ron Melendez Cory Wilkins Actor Sean Murray Ralph Actor Josh Nance Player 2 Actor Mark Nutter Mike Markey Actor Steve Rankin Attorney Trenton Actor Sheeri Rappaport Missy Ross Actor Jordan Reed Player 1 Actor Damara Reilly Lucy Wainswright Actor Tiffany Rudolph Mother 1 Actor Milt Tarver Judge Actor Diana Gould Screenwriter Jonathan Bernstein Producer Joan Barnett Executive Producer Jack Grossbart Executive Producer Geoffrey Erb Cinematographer Sidney Wolinsky Film Editing James McVay Original Music Philp Foreman Production Design Gretchen Goetz Set Decoration Shana Landsburg Casting