Bethany Ashton Wolf Director, Screenwriter Alex Roe Liam Page Actor Jessica Rothe Josie Actor Abby Ryder Fortson Billy Actor Peter Cambor Sam Actor John Benjamin Hickey Pastor Brian Actor Gillian Vigman Doris Actor Travis Tritt Walt Actor Judith Hoag Dr. Whitman Actor Tyler Riggs Jake Actor Morgan Alexandria Kiera Actor Lauren Gros Laura Actor James Rackley Johnny Actor Jason Davis Mr. Guillory Actor Adam Drescher Freddy Actor Bella Lotz Clementine Actor Alison Semenza King Executive Producer Nicole Stojkovich Executive Producer Zach Tann Executive Producer Mickey Liddell Producer Pete Shilaimon Producer Jennifer Monroe Producer Duane Manwiller Cinematographer Priscilla Nedd-Friendly Film Editing Brett Boyett Original Music John Collins Production Design Eulyn Colette Hufkie Costume Design Jeanie Bacharach Casting