A Good Woman


A Good Woman

Critics Consensus

This adaptation of Wilde's Lady Windermere's Fan lacks bite due to liberties taken with the source material, coupled with uneven performances.



Reviews Counted: 81

liked it

Audience Score

User Ratings: 107,274


All Critics | Top Critics
Average Rating: N/A
Reviews Count: 0
Fresh: 0
Rotten: 0


Average Rating: 2.7/5

You may have noticed some of the recent changes we have made. To read more about what we’ve been working on behind the scenes, please check out our new RT Product Blog here.

Want to See

Add Rating
My Rating    

A Good Woman Photos

Movie Info

One of Oscar Wilde's most popular plays is given a new screen interpretation in this period comedy. In New York in the early '30s, Mrs. Erlynne (Helen Hunt) is a widow who lives comfortably through the largesse of several married men, and when she runs out of wealthy suitors in Manhattan, she decides to find greener pastures among the wealthy elite of Italy's Amalfi coast. Mrs. Erlynne sets her sights on Robert Windermere (Mark Umbers), a wealthy Englishman who is married to the young, innocent and very beautiful Meg (Scarlett Johansson). Mrs. Erlynne gingerly tries to separate Robert from his wife and his money, fueling suspicions within Amalfi society as well as the audience that they are involved. Humiliated and ready to beat him at his own game, Meg begins to consider the advances of the handsome Lord Darlington (Stephen Campbell Moore), one of her husband's close friends. In the midst of all the attempted infidelity, the genially eccentric Tuppy (Tom Wilkinson) struggles to win Mrs. Erlynne's hand, while only one of the interconnected parties know that she carries a shocking secret. A Good Woman was based on Wilde's +Lady Windermere's Fan, with its title drawn from that show's subtitle, "A Play About a Good Woman."

Watch it now


Helen Hunt
as Mrs. Erlynne
Scarlett Johansson
as Meg Windermere
Stephen Campbell Moore
as Lord Darlington
Mark Umbers
as Robert Windermere
Milena Vukotic
as Contessa Lucchino
Diana Hardcastle
as Lady Plymdale
Jane How
as Mrs. Stutfield
Giorgia Massetti
as Alessandra
Shara Orano
as Francesca
Bruce McGuire
as Waiter Joe
Michael Stromme
as Hotel Desk Clerk
Valentina D'uva
as Giuseppina
Augusto Zucchi
as Antique Shop Keeper
Carolina Levi
as Dress Shop Salesgirl
Daniela Stanga
as Dress Shop Owner
Arianna Mansi
as Stella's Maid No. 1
Camilla Bertocci
as Stella's Maid No. 2
Nichola Aigner
as Mrs. Gowper
View All

Critic Reviews for A Good Woman

All Critics (81) | Top Critics (31)

  • ... willfully odd movie ...

    Feb 17, 2006 | Rating: 2/4
  • A wet teabag of a movie.

    Feb 16, 2006 | Rating: C

    Keith Phipps

    AV Club
    Top Critic
  • A Good Woman suffers from a staggeringly bad miscasting of its central role and from a cut-and-paste screenplay that substitutes random insertions of Wilde epigrams for character.

    Feb 3, 2006 | Rating: 1.5/4 | Full Review…
  • Something is wrong with A Good Woman: The lightning never strikes. It's never quite alive.

    Feb 3, 2006 | Rating: 2/4 | Full Review…
  • Wilde isn't supposed to be lovely, or charming. He's supposed to be funny, wicked, rude and as full of serious feeling as a lavender butterfly.

    Feb 3, 2006 | Rating: 2/4
  • A Good Woman is such a dreary affair that it makes you wonder whether the last Wilde adaptation -- the critically lambasted The Importance of Being Earnest with Reese Witherspoon -- was really that bad after all.

    Feb 3, 2006 | Rating: 2/4

Audience Reviews for A Good Woman

A woman suspects her husband of infidelity when an older woman who has a sullied reputation comes to town. Why do modern directors and writers think they are smarter than some of the best writers in the English language? In this case, Oscar Wilde's great play Lady Windemere's Fan gets distorted, the worst sin coming in the third act of the film. In addition to alterations in the plot, writer Howard Himelstein interjects some of Wilde's random witticisms into the script; for example, there is little reason why America being the only country to go from barbarism to decadence without civilization in between should be included in the film. It's funny, of course, but out of place. Helen Hunt does not deliver a strong performance. I often thought that Wilde's sophisticated dialogue puts Hunt out of her element, and Scarlett Johannson isn't much better. Obviously the Britons, Tom Wilkinson and Stephen Campbell Moore aren't similarly affected. Overall, the source material is strong, but the film isn't.

Jim Hunter
Jim Hunter

Super Reviewer

What a strange title... almost all the women pissed me off in this movie. I take that back; all the characters pissed me off. There is so much deceit, cheating, and dishonesty going about this plot that we, as the audience, don't know who to root for. There's a group that are the gossipers, Helen Hunt's the seductress, Scarlett Johansson wavers between loyalty and betrayal, and worst of all, Stephen Campbell Moore tries his hardest to break the bond of marriage to satiate his want to sleep with a hot girl. Yeah, you heard me; Campbell Moore says that he does it for the sake of "love" but I call it a booty call, and I make that assumption based on his annoying ass character's mannerisms and actions. What particularly annoyed me the most was how almost everyone within this movie was NOT genuine until the movie decides to wrap everything up with a happy, feel-good ending. "A Good Woman" is put together sloppily with very generic techniques that add nothing to the subpar plot with some of the most annoying side characters I've seen in a very long time. This movie is not worth a watch.

Albert Kim
Albert Kim

Super Reviewer


its an alright film

Film Crazy
Film Crazy

Super Reviewer

The tone of this adaptation is sooo serious and strips away much of Oscar Wilde's bombastic wit. Stephen Campbell Moore is my new It Guy.

Alice Shen
Alice Shen

Super Reviewer

A Good Woman Quotes

News & Features