Dale Peterson Director, Screenwriter Travis Caldwell Vinnie Actor Mary Kate Wiles Kim Actor Hayley Kiyoko Alisa Actor Rachel DiPillo Laura Actor Nate Hartley John Actor James DuMont Dad in Park Actor Brent Briscoe Puggis Actor Wayne Duvall Preacher Actor Tess Harper Aunt Flossie Actor Garrett M. Brown Frank Brown Actor Margaret Kerrison Screenwriter Christine Bartsch Screenwriter Wendy K. Peterson Producer Chris Pluchar Producer April Morris Executive Producer Tanner Wolfe Cinematographer Ken Greenbaum Film Editing Laine Perry Production Design Thomas A. Gilbert Art Director, Set Decoration Emily Ramirez Costume Design Risa Bramon Garcia Casting Steve Maisel Casting