Nick Gomez Director Christina Ricci Lizzie Borden Actor Billy Campbell Andrew Jennings Actor Clea Duvall Emma Actor Stephen McHattie Mr. Borden Actor Sara Botsford Actor Gregg Henry Actor John MacLaren Rev. Edwin A. Buck Actor Brett Donahue Marshal Fleet Actor Andria Wilson Mirza Nance O'Neill Actor Stephen Kay Screenwriter David Coggeshall Screenwriter Michael Mahoney Producer Judith Verno Executive Producer