Gary Yates Director Alicia Witt Melody Jones Actor Brendan Hines Chase Actor Andrea del Campo Jillian Actor Anna Anderson-Epp Lucy Actor Lori Hallier Anne Actor Brandi Alexander Piper Actor Ava Darrach-Gagnon Dot Actor Karen Kruper Connie White Actor Curtis Moore Burt Hooper Actor Blake Taylor Mr. Tyler Actor Doron Bell Mayor Duran Actor Stuart Hughes Hunter Hamilton Actor Darren Felbel Pastor Actor Gino Anania Phillip Green Actor Julie Sherman Wolfe Screenwriter Nancy Grace Executive Producer Josh Sabarra Executive Producer Stan Spry Executive Producer Eric Scott Woods Executive Producer Paul Suderman Cinematographer Jason Irvine Film Editing Matthew Rogers Original Music Penny Perry Casting