Amber Tamblyn Director, Screenwriter, Producer Janet McTeer Meredith Actor, Executive Producer Alia Shawkat Josie Actor Alfred Molina Cal Actor Rhys Wakefield Michael Actor Emily Rios Pen Actor Ashley Blaine Featherson Shirley Mae Actor Annabelle Attanasio Amanda One Actor John Roberts D Actor Nancy Kwan Margaret Actor Ken Davitian Masha The Baker Actor Erik Valdez Officer Valducci Actor Patrick Davis Alarcón Marbles Actor Ed Dougherty Screenwriter Wren Arthur Producer Amy Hobby Producer Anne Hubbell Producer Brian Rigney Hubbard Cinematographer Paul Frank Film Editing Victoria Thomas Casting Markus Kirschner Production Design Monique Dias Art Director Christine Peters Costume Design