Michael Kennedy Director Devon Sawa Robin McAllister Actor Sarah Chalke Marion Fitzwater Actor Joshua Jackson John Prince, Jr. Actor Billy O'Sullivan Will Scarlett Actor Tyler Labine Little John Actor Chad Todhunter Warner Jr. Actor Kevin Hansen Gibson Jr. Actor Colin Cunningham Walter Nottingham Actor Tom Butler John Prince Sr. Actor Annie Charles Rosie Actor James Bell Father Tuck Actor Alf Humphreys Grant McAllister Actor Elizabeth Carol Savenkoff Janet McAllister Actor Larry Sugar Producer