Jesse James Miller Director Lance Henriksen Sheriff Virgil Logan Actor Kailin See Allie Plachtt Actor David Kopp Jason Actor James Kirk Albert Actor Lara Gilchrist Dina Actor Sarah Mutch Lizzie Actor Richard Stroh Paul Actor Kevin McNulty Collier Gatier Actor David Nykl Donny Plachtt Actor Andee Frizzell The Seamstress Actor Aaron Pearl Ryan Caull Actor Jennifer Copping Margaret Caull Actor Norman Misura The Superintendent Actor