Sep 09, 2013
What's most impressive about this film is the fact that Billy Bob Thorton manages to look and sound like a completely different person. And the fact of the matter is that this transformation is simple as hell, sticking your jaw out and changing your voice. Simple, yet highly effective. What can I say about this movie that hasn't been said in the last 17 years since it came out? First things first, I've owned this movie for years now and today was the first time watching. I have the special edition director's cut, which means that the version I watched runs about 2 and 20-some odd minutes long. And not for one second does this movie ever drag or feel like it's running for too long. So that's definitely a positive. The movie tells the story of Karl Childers, who's been in a mental institute for over 25 years for having murdered his wife and her lover, is released and the friendships he develops with a boy, his mother and pretty much everyone he meets, other than Doyle. I thought the writing was excellent and while all characters are really well-written, it doesn't make Karl look like a muppet. He's not someone to be pitied or mocked, he's actually a very kind-hearted, gentle and insightful man. The fact that he did murder his mother and lover isn't really even in your mind once you get to know this man. But, at first, when you meet Karl and he explains to the interviewer how he managed to find himself in that situation, the way this scene is set-up makes Karl sound horrifying. The scene is well-shot and taut. I do think that you can pretty much, right from the beginning of the film, figure out how the film is gonna end. If you've watched more than 20 movies in your life then you'll know. That doesn't mean that the movie isn't compelling, because it's a movie that commands your attention from beginning to end. I must also make special mention of Dwight Yoakam's performance, I thought he was a top-notch asshole in this movie. But, at the same time, he really isn't as bad as you'd have thought. I mean yea, he is a drunk and he yells a lot, but he was never physically abusive, outside of one shoving incident. He is an absolute jerk to Frank though, and he definitely needed to be removed from the equation so Frank and his mother could live happily without having to worry that Doyle was going to go after them. Did he deserved to be murdered? I don't know, it's a moral grey area. I didn't feel horribly sad that Doyle was murdered, but did he deserve it? That's where the dilemma comes in. Another part of the movie I was surprised at was the amount of comedy that was actually in the film. It's not hilarious, it's only a few scenes here and there, but they were a welcome surprise. The comedic highlight would have to be when Doyle and his band return to the house from buying alcohol and they're discussing the band, music, lyrics, etc. So I loved this movie, even if it is a little predictable. This is an excellent movie with a heartfelt story.
Verified