Aharon Keshales Director, Screenwriter, Producer Jason Sudeikis Jimmy Actor Evangeline Lilly Annie Actor Shea Whigham Schmidt Actor Mike Colter Price Actor Michael Paré Joey Actor Amaury Nolasco Manny Actor Jeremy Bobb Frank Actor Tina Parker Alice , parole board Actor Ben Hicks Prison Guard Actor, Screenwriter, Costume Designer Greg Hill Sam Actor Jaime Zevallos Julio Actor Thaddeus J. Mixson Actor Navot Papushado Screenwriter, Producer Roger Birnbaum Producer Chadd Harbold Producer Amanda Presmyk Producer Dallas Sonnier Producer Bobby Campbell Executive Producer Danielle Cox Executive Producer David Gilbery Executive Producer Marlon Vogelgesang Executive Producer Matt Mitchell Cinematographer Bryan Gaynor Film Editor Dave Fleming Original Music Freddy Waff Production Design Tyler Corie Art Director Lindsay Lipscomb Set Decoration David Guglielmo Casting