Paul Wendkos Director Elizabeth Montgomery Lizzie Borden Actor Ed Flanders Hosea Knowlton Actor Katherine Helmond Emma Borden Actor Fionnula Flanagan Bridget Sullivan Actor Don Porter George Robinson Actor Fritz Weaver Mr. Andrew Borden Actor Bonnie Bartlett Sylvia Knowlton Actor John Beal Dr. Bowen Actor Helen Craig Mrs. Abby Borden Actor Alan Hewitt Mayor Coughlin Actor Gail Kobe Alice Russell Actor Robert Symonds Andrew Jennings Actor Hayden Rorke Julien Ralph Actor Iggie Wolfington Store proprietor Actor John Alvin Dr. Draper Actor Joan Crosby Companion Actor Jon Lormer Bailiff Actor J. Edward McKinley Marshall Hilliard Actor Judson Morgan Justice Morgan Actor Tracie Savage Young Lizzie Actor Olan Soule Eli Bence Actor Amzie Strickland Adelaide Churchill Actor Gloria Stuart Store customer Actor Norman Stuart Dr. Wood Actor Patricia Wilson Hannah Reagan Actor Lynn Wood Mrs. Raymond Actor John Zaremba Judge Blaisdell Actor George LeMaire Producer