Edward Burns Gerry Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Producer Kerry Bishé Sharon Actor Heather Burns Erin Actor Marsha Dietlein Dottie Actor Caitlin FitzGerald Connie Actor Anita Gillette Josie Fitzgerald Actor Tom Guiry Cyril Actor Ed Lauter Big Jim Actor Michael McGlone Quinn Actor Nick Sandow Corey Actor Noah Emmerich FX Actor Connie Britton Nora Actor Joyce Van Patten Mrs. McGowan Actor Dara Coleman JJ Actor Brian d'Arcy James Skippy Actor Daniella Pineda Abbie Actor Aaron Lubin Producer William Rexer Producer, Cinematographer Mike Harrop Executive Producer Janet Gaynor Film Editing P.T. Walkley Original Music Maribeth Fox Casting