Matt Riddlehoover Marty Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Producer, Film Editing Declan Gallagher Narrator Amy Kelly Isabelle , Margaret , Pervert Actor Phil Leirness Ray Actor Starina Johnson Natasha Actor Luís Lucas Victor Actor Andrew Matarazzo Alex Actor Heather Horton Carol Actor Cesar D' La Torre Miguel Actor Ethan James Screenwriter, Casting Thashana McQuiston Screenwriter Shane Bartlett Producer, Cinematographer Ryan Basham Producer Sean P. Williams Executive Producer Josh Robbins Executive Producer Ricky Stanker Executive Producer Joe Hill Executive Producer Serena Isquirdo Garcia Costume Design Chris J. Armenta Casting