Karen Maine Director, Screenwriter, Executive Producer Natalia Dyer Alice Actor Christian Adam Student #1 Actor Susan Blackwell Gina Actor Alisha Boe Nina Actor Donna Lynne Champlin Mrs. Veda Actor Myles Evans Student #2 Actor Gavrielle Anne Fontanilla Student , Altar Server Actor Zachary Forsythe Jacob Actor Timothy Simons Father Murphy Actor Francesca Reale Laura Actor Teesha Renee Beth Actor Wolfgang Novogratz Chris Actor Parker Wierling Wade Actor Katie Cordeal Producer Colleen Hammond Producer Eleanor Columbus Producer Rodrigo Teixeira Producer Chris Columbus Executive Producer Arianne Fraser Executive Producer Sophie Mas Executive Producer Delphine Perrier Executive Producer Lourenço Sant' Anna Executive Producer Todd Antonio Cinematographer Jennifer Lee Film Editing Ian Hultquist Original Music Sally Levi Production Design Samantha LaRoe McDonald Set Decoration Brittany Loar Costume Design Rebecca Dealy Casting Jessica Kelly Casting